There are several translations available of Musashi's book of five
rings. Two of the best translations are the one published by the
Overlook Press and translated by Victor Harris and the one published
by Shambahala and translated by Thomas Cleary. The Overlook Press
was the first company to release an English version of the book
and make it popular. Much of its original success was due to good
marketing and targeting the book at business people, touting it
as the secret to Japan's success in the business world. Quotes such
as "Japan's Answer to the Harvard MBA", referring to the strategy
in A Book of Five Rings, were put on the cover. The book
did very well and other companies followed with their own translations.
The language of the text of this version is more philosophical and
abstract, so it is good for thinking of how the concepts of strategy
apply to other areas. It also includes several pictures and a longer
historical background on Musashi and the time period in which he
lived.
For someone more interested in the martial arts or sword fighting
techniques, Thomas Cleary does a good job in making the language
more concrete in terms of how Musashi's words refer to specific
body movements and fighting techniques. The translation overall
is also written in a straightforward manner that is more understandable
to English speakers. Also included in this book are some of the
writings of Yagyu Munenori, who lived during the same time as Musashi,
and was the sword instructor of the Shogun. As these two books by
Thomas Cleary and Victor Harris have their own feeling and strengths,
reading both versions is advisable for getting a deeper understanding
and appreciation of The Book of Five Rings.
Other notable translations include the one by D.E Tarver, William
Scott Wilson, and Steven Kaufman. For other information on Musashi,
the book, Musashi Miyamoto: His Life and Writings, is an
excellent, in depth resource. It has a lot of information about
Musashi that is hard to find elsewhere as well as containing its
own translation of The Book of Five Rings. Another good resource
is The Japanese Art of War by Thomas Cleary, which explores the
concept and history of the Samurai Zen Warrior.
|